Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise (2025)

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise is a 2025 mystery film that tells the compelling story of Cheryl, a woman reeling from the heartbreak of a broken three-year engagement. Looking for a fresh start, Cheryl accepts an invitation from her aunt to leave behind her life in Chicago and relocate to the quiet Amish town of Sugarcreek, Ohio.

Cheryl’s transition into this deeply traditional community is anything but smooth. As she adjusts to the slower pace and unfamiliar customs, she stumbles upon a troubling secret that threatens to disrupt the peace and values of the entire town. Her journey evolves from one of escape into one of purpose, as she digs deeper into the mystery surrounding Sugarcreek.

Directed by Sandra L. Martin and written by D.F.W. Buckingham, the film captures a beautiful blend of cultural contrast and personal discovery. As Cheryl immerses herself in the lives of those around her, she not only works to solve the mystery but also uncovers the true meaning of family, acceptance, and belonging.

Movie Information

Cast